Paul Fronczak / Kevin Baty at birth / Michael Reese Hospital Chicago

Dora and Chester after the abduction

(LO via AP)

News sketch of potential kidnapper

(UPI)

Paul Joseph Fronczak / Jack Rosenthal after he’s found by Newark Police

(AP)

Paul Fronczak today

(Marcus Villagran / Las Vegas Review-Journal via AP Images)

Rendering of what Paul would look like

(ABC News via Phojoe)

Paul Fronczak / Kevin Baty as an infant; Kevin Baty as an adult

(Paul Fronczak / Kevin Baty at birth / Michael Reese Hospital Chicago; Kevin Ray Baty / findagrave.com)

The Foundling

(Paul Fronczak / The Foundling)

Georgia:

Paul Fronczak’s Triple Disappearance

Episode sources:

1. “A reporter was haunted by a Portland family’s 1958 disappearance. Her daughter saw the mystery to its end” by Fedor Zarkhin (The Oregonian) 2025

2. “An Oregon Family Vanished in 1958. Their Car May Have Been Found in a River.” By Simon J. Levien (The New York Times) 2025

3. “In 1958, The Martin Family Suddenly Vanished — And Oregon Police Still Don’t Know What Exactly Happened” by Genevieve Carlton, Edited by John Kuroski (All That’s Interesting) 2026

4. “Diver says human remains found in car connected to 1958 Portland cold case” by Spencer Schacht (KPTV) 2025

5. “Special documentary 50 years after Martin family’s disappearance” (KOIN 6) 2018

6. “Friends Rate Missing Ken Martin as Top-Flight Santa in Candy Lane” (The Oregonian) 1958

7. “Cold waters of the Columbia cradle secrets closely” by Ann Sullivan (The Oregonian) 1986

8. “After Martin family disappeared, theories obsessed police, journalists” by Fedor Zarkhin (The Oregonian) 2025

Karen:

The 1990 Michigan Wedding Sting

Episode sources:

1. “Most Likely to Succeed” by John Cloud (Time Magazine) 1999

2. “The Boys Next Door” by Maureen O’Hagen (Willamette Week) 1998

3. “Runner’s High” by Julian Balsey (Grant Magazine) 2023

4. “Star Student Comes Home to Robbery Charges” (The New York Times) 1998

5. “Teen robbery suspect arrested at Las Vegas hotel” (Las Vegas Sun) 1998

6. “Tom Curtis -- student body president and armed robber -- freed from prison” by Michelle Cole (The Oregonian) 2009

7. “A Kids Book About Incarceration” by Ethan Thrower

8. “Teen Felon Nabbed in Vegas” (CBS News) 1998

9. “Earlier stories about Tom Curtis and his string of robberies” by Jerry Casey (Oregonian) 2009

Nancy Reagan in the 1986 “Just Say No” address

Flint, MI

(Don Harrison / CC BY-NC-ND 2.0 Generic / Flickr)

Moon, bottom left, with contraband

(Shiawassee County Sheriff's Department)

Moon getting into his “wedding” tux

(Shiawassee County Sheriff's Department)

SPOC Band Tees

(Shiawassee County Sheriff's Department)

Debbie, with Vic Wasylyshyn standing behind her in the track suit

(Shiawassee County Sheriff's Department)

Debbie, left, Moon, right, apprehending a suspect at the “wedding”

(Shiawassee County Sheriff's Department)